Same Old Place Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing Same Old Place, a cozy pizza joint in Jamaica Plain, MA, known for its thin-crust Italian pizzas and friendly staff. With a diverse menu offering breakfast items like egg sandwiches and bagels, appetizers including Buffalo wings and mozzarella sticks, and a savory soup of the day, this restaurant has something for everyone. Customers rave about the delicious cheese pizza, steak and cheese, and chop cheese, all made with top-notch ingredients. The restaurant also offers a military discount and caters to groups and kids. Whether you dine in, take out, or order delivery, Same Old Place guarantees a satisfying meal with a homey vibe and excellent service. Don't miss out on this neighborhood gem for a taste of authentic, reliable Italian cuisine.
Breakfast
Egg sandwich
Bacon , ham or sausage egg cheese
Egg and cheese sandwich
Bacon sausage or ham
Egg breafast
2 egg any style bacon sausage or ham and hash browns
Bagel cream cheese
Plain bagel or everything bagel
Coffe tea
Buffalo Chicken Wings
Wing Dings
Chicken Fingers
Buffalo Fingers
Mozzarella Sticks
Jalapeno Poppers
Steak Fries
Onion Rings
Garlic Bread
Chicken Quesadillas
Side of Meatballs
Side of Italian Sausage
Buffalo Wings
Canjun fries
Bacon cheese fries
Sweet chili wings
Sweet chili chicken fingers
Appetizers
Soup
Soup of the Day
Please call restaurants for daily soup selection.
Garden Salad
Chef Salad
Grilled Chicken Salad
Tuna Salad
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Greek Grilled Chicken Salad
Greek Salad
Antipasto Salad
Crispy Chicken Salad
Chicken Salad
Crabmeat Salad
Caesar Salad
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Tossed Salad
Tossed Salad with Chicken Salad
Tossed Salad with Crabmeat Salad
Tossed Salad with Tuna
Steak tips salad
Salad
Salads
Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Super Special Pizza
Veggie Special Pizza
Meat Lovers Pizza
1 Topping Pizza
2 Topping Pizza
3 Topping Pizza
4 Topping Pizza
Double Cheese Pizza
Half Meat Lover Half Veggie Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
The Hilson Pizza
Cheeseburger and onion.
The Regina Pizza
Garlic, tomato, basil and parm.
The White Pizza
Cheese and garlic. No Sauce.
Gluten Free 10" Pizza
Cheese Calzone Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Sicilian 18" Pizza
#1 Special Pizza by the Slice
2 slices of cheese pizza and small soda.
#2 Special Pizza by the Slice
Two slices pepperoni and bottle of soda.
#3 Special Pizza by the Slice
1 slice cheese and 1 pepperoni slice and a small soda.
Slice of Cheese Pizza
Slice of Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza by the Slice
Specialty Pizza
The Boss Pizza
Steak, onion and cheese.
The Marcello Pizza
Salami, onion and mushroom.
The Tito Pizza
Grilled chicken and broccoli.
The Eric Pizza
Grilled chicken, tomato and jalapeno.
The Macho Pizza
Served with meatball and sausage.
The Greek Pizza
Feta, tomato, spinach and olive.
The Sweet, Salty and Spicy Pizza
Pineapple, bacon and jalapeno. Spicy.
The Go Green Pizza
Broccoli, spinach, garlic and artichoke.
The BLT Pizza
Bacon, chopped tomato and shredded lettuce.
The Rancher Pizza
Crispy chicken, bacon, tomato and ranch dressing.
Rhode Island Burger
Plain.
Vermont Burger
With Cheese.
Massachusetts Burger
With lettuce and our dressing.
Connecticut Burger
With sauteed peppers.
New Hampshire Burger
With sauteed mushrooms.
Maine Burger
With raw onion.
New England Burger
With mushrooms and peppers.
Cheeseburger Combo
Served with choice of fries or onion rings.
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Breakfast Burger
With egg and bacon.
Burgers
Pasta
Spaghetti sauce
Spahetti pasta sauce.
Stuffed Shells
Served with sauce.
Chicken Broccoli Alfredo Pasta
Lasagna
Ziti
Ziti with Meatballs
Ziti with Sausage
Ziti with Chicken
Ziti with Eggplant
Wing Ding Dinner
Includes side salad and fries or onion rings.
Chicken Finger Dinner
Includes side salad and fries or onion rings.
Fish and Chips Dinner
Includes side salad and fries or onion rings.
Steak tips
Comes with frys
Dinners
Gyros
Grilled Chicken Gyro
Comes with lettuce, tomato. olives, feta cheese, and tzatziki on a grilled pita.
Beef Gyro
Comes with lettuce, tomato. olives, feta cheese, and tzatziki on a grilled pita.
Hamburger Club
Cheeseburger Club
Turkey Club
Tuna Club Sandwich
Ham and Cheese Club Sandwich
Roast Beef Club Sandwich
Includes bacon, lettuce tomato and mayo. Served with your choice of steak fries or onion rings and a side salad served with house dressing.
Chicken Salad Club
Includes bacon, lettuce tomato and mayo. Served with your choice of steak fries or onion rings and a side salad served with house dressing.
Club Sandwiches
Subs
Steak Sub
Steak Bomb Sub
Italian Sausage Sub
Meatball Sub
Chicken Cutlet Sub
Chicken Parm Sub
Eggplant Parm Sub
Pepper and Egg Sub
Western Sub
BLT Sub
Hot Pastrami Sub
Cheeseburger Sub
Grilled Chicken Sub
Chicken Stir Fry Sub
Italian Cold Cuts Sub
Ham and Cheese Sub
Sliced Turkey Sub
Tuna Sub
Chicken Salad Sub
Ham and cheese
Tuna fish
Pastrami
Steak and cheese
Medium steak
Large Steak sub
Buffalo Blue Wrap
Chicken Stir Fry Wrap
Greek Grilled Chicken Wrap
Marinated Steak Tips Wrap
Hawaiian Wrap
Supreme Turkey Wrap
Vegetarian Wrap
Vegetarian.
BBQ Chicken Wrap
Wraps
Calzones
Cheese Calzone
1 Topping Calzone
2 Topping Calzone
3 Topping Calzone
4 Topping Calzone
Super Special Calzone
Veggie Special Calzone
Meat Lover Calzone
Kids Spaghetti
With sauce.
Kids Grilled Cheese
Kids Chicken Fingers
Kids Menu
Dessert
Peanut Butter Cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Fudge Brownies
2 Liter Bottled Soda
Canned Soda
Juice
20 oz. Water
Red Bull
Pepsi
20oz Bottle
Diet Coke
20oz
Monster
Beverages
Catering Appetizers
Catering Buffalo Chicken Wings
Catering Wing Dings
Catering Chicken Fingers
Catering Buffalo Fingers
Catering Mozzarella Sticks
Catering Jalapeno Poppers
Catering Steak Fries
Catering Onion Rings
Catering Garlic Bread
Catering Chicken Quesadillas
Catering Side of Meatballs
Catering Side of Italian Sausage
Catering Garden Salad
Catering Chef Salad
Catering Grilled Chicken Salad
Catering Tuna Salad
Catering Buffalo Chicken Salad
Catering Greek Grilled Chicken Salad
Catering Marinated Steak Tip Salad
Catering Greek Salad
Catering Antipasto Salad
Catering Crispy Chicken Salad
Catering Chicken Salad
Catering Caesar Salad
Catering Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad
Catering Salads
Catering Pizza
Catering Cheese Pizza
Catering Super Special Pizza
Catering Veggie Special Pizza
Catering Meat Lovers Pizza
Catering 10" Gluten Free Pizza
Catering Cheese Calzone Pizza
Catering 18" Sicilian Pizza
#1 Catering Special Pizza by the Slice
2 slices of cheese pizza and small soda.
#2 Catering Special Pizza by the Slice
2 slices pepperoni and bottle of soda.
#3 Catering Special Pizza by the Slice
1 slice cheese and 1 pepperoni slice and a small soda.
Catering Slice of Cheese Pizza
Catering Slice of Pepperoni Pizza
Catering Sicilian Slice
Catering Pizza by the Slice
Catering Specialty Pizza
Catering The Boss Pizza
Steak, onion and cheese.
Catering The Marcello Pizza
Salami, onion and mushroom.
Catering The Tito Pizza
Grilled chicken and broccoli.
Catering The Eric Pizza
Grilled chicken, tomato and jalapeno.
Catering The Macho Pizza
Served with meatball and sausage.
Catering The Greek Pizza
Feta, tomato, spinach and olive.
Catering The Sweet, Salty and Spicy Pizza
Pineapple, bacon and jalapeno. Spicy.
Catering The Go Green Pizza
Broccoli, spinach, garlic and artichoke.
Catering The BLT Pizza
Bacon, chopped tomato and shredded lettuce.
Catering The White Pizza
Cheese and garlic, and no sauce.
Catering The Rancher Pizza
Crispy chicken, bacon, tomato and ranch dressing.
Catering Cheese Calzone
Catering 1 Topping Calzone
Catering 2 Toppings Calzone
Catering 3 Toppings Calzone
Catering 4 Toppings Calzone
Catering Super Special Calzone
Catering Veggie Special Calzone
Catering Meat Lover Calzone
Catering Calzones
Catering Burgers
Catering Rhode Island Burger
Plain.
Catering Vermont Burger
Comes with cheese.
Catering Massachusetts Burger
Served with lettuce and our dressing.
Catering Connecticut Burger
Comes with sauteed peppers.
Catering New Hampshire Burger
Comes with sauteed mushrooms.
Catering Maine Burger
Comes with raw onion.
Catering New England Burger
Comes with mushrooms and peppers.
Catering Cheeseburger Combo
Served with choice of fries or onion rings.
Catering Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Catering Hot Dog
Catering Breakfast Burger
Comes with egg and bacon.
Catering Spaghetti Sauce
Spahetti pasta sauce. Add meatballs, sausage, chicken or eggplant for an additional charge.
Catering Stuffed Shells
Served with sauce.
Catering Chicken Broccoli Alfredo Pasta
Catering Lasagna
Add meatballs, sausage, chicken or eggplant for an additional charge.
Catering Ravioli
Add meatballs, sausage, chicken or eggplant for an additional charge.
Catering Ziti
Catering Ziti with Meatballs
Catering Ziti with Sausage
Catering Ziti with Chicken
Catering Ziti with Eggplant
Catering Pasta
Catering Dinners
Catering Marinated Steak Tip Dinner
Includes side salad and fries or onion rings.
Catering Wing Ding Dinner
Includes side salad and fries or onion rings.
Catering Chicken Finger Dinner
Includes side salad and fries or onion rings.
Catering Honey Fried Chicken Dinner
Includes side salad and fries or onion rings.
Catering Fish and Chips Dinner
Includes side salad and fries or onion rings.
Catering Grilled Chicken Gyro
Comes with lettuce, tomato. olives, feta cheese, and tzatziki on a grilled pita.
Catering Beef Gyro
Comes with lettuce, tomato. olives, feta cheese, and tzatziki on a grilled pita.
Catering Gyros
Catering Club Sandwiches
Catering Hamburger Club Sandwich
Catering Cheeseburger Club Sandwich
Catering Turkey Club Sandwich
Catering Tuna Club Sandwich
Catering Ham and Cheese Club Sandwich
Catering Steak Sub
Catering Steak and Cheese Sub
Catering Steak Bomb Sub
Catering Italian Sausage Sub
Catering Meatball Sub
Catering Chicken Cutlet Sub
Catering Chicken Parm Sub
Catering Eggplant Parm Sub
Catering Pepper and Egg Sub
Catering Western Sub
Catering BLT Sub
Catering Cheeseburger Sub
Catering Grilled Chicken Sub
Catering Chicken Stir Fry Sub
Catering Steak Tips Sub
Catering Italian Cold Cuts Sub
Catering Ham and Cheese Sub
Catering Sliced Turkey Sub
Catering Roast Beef Sub
Catering Tuna Sub
Catering Chicken Salad Sub
Catering Crabmeat Sub
Catering Tuna Fish Sub
Catering Subs
Catering Wraps
Catering Buffalo Blue Wrap
Catering Chicken Stir Fry Wrap
Catering Greek Grilled Chicken Wrap
Catering Marinated Steak Tips Wrap
Catering Hawaiian Wrap
Catering Supreme Turkey Wrap
Catering Vegetarian Wrap
Catering BBQ Chicken Wrap
Catering Kids Spaghetti
Served with sauce.
Catering Kids Grilled Cheese
Catering Kids Chicken Fingers
Catering Kids Menu
Catering Desserts
Catering Peanut Butter Cookies
Catering Chocolate Chip Cookies
Catering Fudge Brownies
Catering Ben and Jerry's Ice Cream
1 pint size flavors: cherry garcia, 1/2 baked, chocolate fudge brownie, chunky monkey, phish food, American dream, tonight dough milk and cookies, peanut butter cup, chocolate chip cookie dough gimme smore Netflix and chilled cubby hubby.
Catering Bottled Drink
20 oz.